There comes a time when you realize you’ll never take the writing world by storm. Like your heroes. You aren’t a prodigy.
But you keep writing anyway..
You won’t sell your first story to your favorite magazine. You won’t sell all your stories. (A few folks do!)
But you keep writing anyway.
There comes a time when you realize that your day job goes on… well. Maybe forever. You may realize this before or after you start selling things. Before or after your first story or novella or novel is published. Before or afterr you first award nomination. Before or after your Kirkus reviews. Before or after your Hugo or Nebula award.
But you keep writing anyway.
There comes a time when you realize you will never be a fresh face. Your author photo for your first book, if it ever gets published, is gonna be this worn around the edges middle-aged person. Nobody will ever look at you and want to be you. Not if they have to look like you, be as old as you. Your face will not sell a single book. Your books will have to sell themselves.
But you keep writing anyway.
You eventually realize that your books will not do for you what books written by others do. You are performing magic tricks, that work best for others. You can amuse yourself, but you cannot tickle yourself. You can surprise yourself, but after that moment of surprise, there’s a ton of mechanical toil.
But you keep writing anyway.
There comes a time when it gets harder to read; when things you read and loved no longer work for you, when you grow jealous of authors of things you cannot imagine ever writing, when you grow weary of reading things you feel you could have written yourself. Or written better.
But you keep writing anyway.
There comes a time when it all gets to be too much; the ambivalence of friends, family, workshop, market, editors, awards process, agents, publishers, one star reviewers. The pile of unsold work so much taller than the pile of stuff sold. The mental calculation of how much per hour writing has made you. If anything, after you factor in the courses and retreats and professional memberships and research expenses.
And you stop writing. For a time. You have better, or more necessary, things to do.
And those other things consume you, and then, recede, and the disappointments fade, and the memory of the accomplishments glows, and the friendships shine brighter than the ambivalence and tribal bickering. You remember this hidden world inside, infinite, largely untapped, your own godlike ability to imagine into being that which would require billion dollar budgets to render on film.
Nobody needs to green light you—except you.
You get the exact same blank page to write on that every single writer you ever loved was given. Your materials are just as good.
You have time. Some time. Some have more time than others. That isn’t fair. That doesn’t have to stop you cold. You have some time. And you can do this. Because you have before, And you are still you, a version of you, and will always be some version of you.
And you find yourself writing again, for no reason, for fun, with no expectations, with great expectations, and when you write, you’re a writer. You get to be one. You are one.
For as long as you want to be. For as long as you can.
I’ve been thinking about death a lot lately. If death is possible think about it. Grasp, believe in, and truly accept.
I’m only young now to an 80 year old, but I have like a young person dealt with death with denial. Intellectually I know about it. I don’t believe in Santa Claus or Heaven. But viscerally, even though I have at times been suicidal, I have never wrapped my mind around my death, or the deaths of those closest to me.
As COVID takes a 911 worth of lives every few days, as I grapple with the deaths of my parents, my ending becomes more real, and yet, never comes into focus. It’s a hole in my retina. It’s in my blind spot. I catch glimpses. Evoking horror. Or a curious numbness. But mostly, I’m no closer to any understanding or closure.
Instead this gasping fear, this hideous dread, of finding myself in the hospital or hospice bed with my sad family gathered around me. Saying goodbye.
Or it’s an abstraction, devoid of panic, fear, only a mix of sadness and an attempt at acceptance and resignation. Aphorisms. For everything a season. He lived a rich and full life and was loved.
Everything dies, my mother said. That’s just the way it is. And if I’m going to die, I wish I would and get it over with. This said while she was in uncontrollable pain for a month or so.
So I’m left wondering, what do I do with my fucking life, now that I know, at some level, my days are numbered? What matters enough to do? To give myself to utterly?
It’s down to writing. Some part of me wants to join some mythical brigade of tree planting climate warriors. Or armed defenders of the weak against the rising right-wing white supremacist GOP fronted menace that threatens anyone and everyone but those most like me. But what the fuck, when has that ever been me? I got closest to that with my trans kid, writing about and learning about them, fighting online for them, and once virally boosting a boycott that helped shut down a few right wing radio jocks.
I had businesses contacting me begging to be taken off their show’s sponsor list.
But mostly I have gamboled and angsted perched on some high terrace of Maslow’s heirarchy of needs.
And I want to throw myself into something. Completely. Make some small mark. Be for something. Be about something. Time not on my side. At an age when many of my heroes have been dead for years.
Trying not to stare into the sun and blind myself. Trying to snap out of the daydream of immortality. Withdraw from the anodyne of streaming media. Leave the party and roll up my sleeves and get to work. Work eighteen hours a day, to make up for all the lost time. All the self-indulgence.
Until the end.
Until I am dragged, kicking and screaming into the unknowable.
The markets that publish me that have made me feel like a ‘real writer,’ have a 20k suggested word cap, which I have successfully pushed out a few thousand words a few times. But my shorts have grown longer and longer, and now everything I write becomes a novella, which I sell every other time or so.
I write novel starts… and hit a hard wall at 40k. The unpublished novellas I believed in so much haunt me. I stare at the wall. I don’t write.
My supports, writing community, friends and editors haven’t, as yet, been able to shove me up and over that wall in the spec fic genres.
I have endings in mind that call to me, and my scattering of milestones that I pants my way toward. I have finished a few short novels in other genres. But with SF, which I feel is my true calling, I stall out.
Nothing in my work has ever been called ground breaking. And that, for a long time, was what I thought was the point of SF. To be something new under the sun. Gradually I realized I read a lot of entertaining SF, and loved it, that explored old tropes in new-ish ways, or simply executed well on old tropes—with great plots and characters. Good world-building. And I liked that stuff.
Everything I liked wasn’t a part of this huge tapestry of extrapolation that SF has woven through my world, through my understanding of the odd future we now live inside, and the even odder ones to come. Sometimes what I love is just good writing and enjoyable reading. Reinforcing that fabric. Overlaying it. Singing in harmony with it, to abruptly abandon the cloth metaphor.
I first first realized this while reading SF magazines, and it let me write. I didn’t have to be a genius. I could be me. There were stories I could write, that maybe only I could write. In Nancy Kress’s Beginnings, Middles and Ends, she says that all writers have the Dostoevsky problem. Eventually realizing they will never be Dostoevsky, and wondering, what the fuck is the point of this difficult activity?
This is often after the writer comes face to face with the reality that most authors do not making anything like a living. At best, fiction is a part time gig. Those that do it full time usually have patrons. This is one reason we get too much white het cis rich guy fiction. We also get fiction from their white het cis wives, and their white het cis children. But whether you are struggling to make a living, or another well-supported white het cis guy, the Dostoevsky problem remains.
Writers are haunted by reviews. Writing workshop critiques can be painful, and professional rejections sometimes worse, but a review on a finished published work takes the psychic horror to a new level. This is a reader, who took a chance on you. You failed them. With this thing you loved.
One of the hardest reviews for me, was a 4 star review which said, “nothing groundbreaking, but my favorite story in the issue.”
I nodded. I knew that, didn’t I? I beat this problem before, didn’t I?
But after 40,000 words, knowing that my editors that believe in me are no longer in the loop, I lose steam.
I revise a lot now. Even 40k is an endless abyss of editing, which isn’t painful at all, it’s sort of fun for me, but I shudder to think how long my novels are gonna take to write. Will I get faster? I’m fucking 58. Why would I get any faster?
So I struggle. Hoping always to become that person that climbs that wall. Maybe tomorrow. If I am lucky to live long enough, maybe I get there.
Down the street from me sits a dark shingled, two story home oddly canted in its sizable lot, surrounded by this purple fence densely inscribed with inscrutable ramblings. I have heard that his house was built on another lot, which some big institution wanted, and they moved it here at great expense, and he had them orient it along a north south axis for mystical reasons.
The guy must be wealthy; the house and property would go for a few million now. Cambridge hasn’t figured out, yet, how to squash this guy’s identity with zoning regulations. The stuff on the fence reminds me schizophrenia, but it isn’t a nasty sort. It’s all curiously upbeat. Or at worst, opaque.
One part of the wall has a huge moose silhouette on it, labeled, the cosmic moose. I love it.
This public identity works for this guy, who dresses like a hippie, in rainbow threaded embroidered layers. We used to sit in cafes together. He had a shoulder bag full of action figurines he would set up around him on his table, before he started writing in his spiral notebook.
This identity works for this guy. My hat’s off to him.
My identity doesn’t work. My social media identity. Maybe my entire identity down to the core, but let’s start picking away at the upper layer first, shall we?
So, everyone knows the aphorism about insanity being doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result.
This is the top line of what I am now trying to do with my relationship, broadly, to the internet. I mean, to stop doing that, to be clear. This isn’t about Facebook and Twitter and blogging; this is about everything flowing through the broadband pipe. News. Streaming movies and TV. Oversharing. Finding freelance work. How I exist as a political being. Everything. All of it, more or less at once.
I’m trying to not do the same things, over and over again, and expect a different result.
My single identity, the train wreck, we can call it, rams together overshares, accountability posts, my professional ambition, my teaching impulses, my attempts to find freelance work, my posting of creative work, and my vitriolic politics, shot through with cries of fury and despair at, uh, lots of infuriating and despair-inducing things.
This can work, if one is a genius. If you’re Kanye West, you can do whatever the fuck you want, and you will continue to make a living. Sure, some people will think you’re an asshole. But you can just chug along and keep making hits, being a nut, shrugging off the articles you see about how maybe the media should not broadcast your bipolar issues. You don’t even have to admit you’re bipolar!
I’m not Kanye West.
As I try to pull this blog together, I am realizing that I need a set of outlets for each kind of content, with appropriate audiences for each. I need to curate separate identities, or, simply move some identities out of the web all together.
I have, for sometime, wondered, am I just not trying hard to enough, to do the stuff I want to do, or, does my social media identity sabotage my efforts?
The internet is forever; to some degree I will never escape the identity I have built with 10,000 posts. But I can at least tidy this shit up. Curate what I am putting out there now. I’m not important, and so relatively few people are gonna hold stuff against me if I just make sure that shit is gone when they look for me, professionally, do that sanity check, we all do, when we have to create any kind of new relationship.
So this site if a transitional object. What does the endgame look like?
The writer-author-teacher identity.
The graphic designer illustrator identity.
The personal identity’s internet footprint / residue.
The political identity.
I could do the personal is political thing, merge the two, that’s understandable. But personal, political and business and creative all rammed together in one steaming mess?
That doesn’t work. For me. I’m not Kanye.
And I need to stop pretending I ever will be, or that this will ever work.
The amount of work to do in all this is daunting; the desire to burn everything to the ground is great. But I have made many wonderful friends and had many meaningful interactions in the social media space, all of which of course, helped Mark Zuckerberg get paid to elect Donal Trump president.
That has to stop. I have to stop doing that.
So I’m trying. To save the best, to abandon the rest, and that, I am now admitting, is going to take time and effort.
Maybe they belittle your writing. Remind you it’s just a hobby. Ask if you’ve been published and then how much that paid. Remind you not to quit your day job. Or they dismiss your genre completely. It isn’t literature.
Or they pay lip service, provide generalized support…
…but never actually read you. Or if they do? They don’t mention it.
And of course, they never write reviews.
Yeah. That’s a thing. My wife and kids and most of my pre-writing friends don’t read my work. In the 90s I used to flog them with it, as I sold to semi-pro markets. Even the wife, kid, and friends who are SF readers never read me. And my wife reads several hours of genre fiction a day.
She could get through my published work in three weeks.
Ouch. Oh, and the amazing thing is, you can actually blog this, and not worry about it, because they’ll never notice, because they don’t read the blog either.
Maniacal laughter. Sullen staring. Rubbing of the temples.
It’s tough. You rely on these people to some degree for emotional support, or financial support, your whole life, and then, when it comes time to validate the time you have poured into this… they can’t put in a few hours of effort to inspect the output.
Why?
Who knows.
Look. It’s weird. Believing in someones prose, anyone’s prose, is a kind of hard work. Entering that willing suspension of disbelief. Losing yourself in someone else’s story. Your friends and family carry all this baggage about you, your strengths, your failings, your blind spots, and as they read your work, sometimes, this memory of you stands on their shoulder, this grinning homunculus poking them in the face. Who is this character supposed to be? Who is this romantic interest? Oh gross, my Dad is thinking about sex?
You get the idea.
Of course, some friends or family will read what you’ve written, and tell you what’s wrong with it. How to fix it. That’s hard to deal with too. Are they writing and publishing in the places you do? No. But they can tell you why your work isn’t working. For them.
So what is the answer?
Let this go. It doesn’t matter. You’re being a drama queen. This is life, dude. Yeah, other people’s wives, kids, family, friends read their stuff and LOVE it…. yeah. You’re not them. Deal with it. Move on.
If they aren’t editors, if they aren’t agents, they’re just a few random people you happen to know. With random opinions. Sure, they’re your people. But they aren’t your readers, and they will probably never be. You don’t work for them.
Someday some of them may get on board. Probably not. I thought, if I started publishing a lot in bigger magazines….
Nope!
But I like to think after I’m gone, when my kids are longing to hear my voice, that they can pick up some of what I write, and read it, and smile, and hear me again.
Why not? It’s a harmless thing to imagine.That we win in the end. After we’re gone. The payoff. It’s the ultimate existential loophole of the artist. I’m fucking Van Gogh who sold two paintings and some drawings in his life. Prove I’m not.
You can’t.
It’s a cheat. But use it. What we’re doing is hard. You can’t let the opinions of random people get you down. Slow you down. Shut you down. Or stop you.
I lost the ability to fall into a book, lose myself in fiction, sometime back, decades ago, I guess. Writing, trying to write, being frustrated by rejection, scrutinizing and workshopping my text and the texts of others impaired my ability to just slip into the prose.
So I pushed through it.
I still found books that grabbed me, that tugged me along, that gave me the old feeling I used to get from literally every book I read. But more and more started things and did not finish them. Did not feel drawn to finish them.
And the amount of time I could read, that felt normal to read, slipped to about a chapter. I’d read one, enjoy it, close the book. Ruminate on it. And feel full. Also, perpetually sleep deprived, I’d relax while reading, and pass out.
I read a thousand books from the age of 14-18 or so, a book a night most nights for three years. In later years I veered away from reading only SF and fantasy and horror and read literary stuff, old and new, and some other genre’s, a little mystery, true crime, historical fiction, and non-fiction, generally pop-science books my father recommended.
The kid that read a thousand books was miserable of course. Desperately seeking to escape from his life. His perfectly ordinary and trauma free life, I have to add. I suffered from no privation, no abuse. Nowadays they would call me bipolar with ADHD, and could sling some pharmaceuticals in my direction. Not sure if that would have helped. Probably.
But my reading slowed way the fuck down as I found a group of friends to run around with as a late teenager. Tons of friends. I had friends who didn’t party, as we used to say in the late seventies, who I loved, who I walked with and talked with and drew with and worked on Dungeons and Dragons with. And I had my doper friends, and then I had girlfriends, who mixed to some degree with my male friends.
We hung out that way, mostly, until we went to college, and even there, often. Same sex friend groups with these gender foreign exchange student type people who came along with one of your friends.
Surrounded by friends, having a girlfriend, making art, I still read, I think, but not as much. I was still weird in so many ways but my life was full. I think I read then more to explore the world than to be comforted by not being myself. Me and my friends imbibed stale hippy culture that was being eroded steadily by time and reality, and the rising conservatism which would sweep Reagan into office.
When I moved to Jamaica Plain (which I just called ‘Boston,’) I cut myself off from all that. Left all my friends behind. I followed my girlfriend who would become my wife, but with no other friends. I read again. Not a book a night, but more. And I read things that I had always wanted to read that would have upset my father to see lying around the house.
I read about western mysticism; early christianity, UFOs, paranormal phenomena, socialism, communism and intentional community, utopias. I subscribed to The Nation. My parents were centrist democrats. And I started reading the newspaper.
As a kid, I thought reading a daily newspaper was cool. My parents did it effortlessly, like breathing, and I thought that it was a very grown up thing to do. I would struggle through an article, now and then, my eyes grinding to a halt every few paragraphs. When I started devouring fiction, my parents would look up from their newspapers and magazines and say how much they had loved reading fiction, once upon a time, but now they had a much smaller appetite for it.
So I had my kids, twenty three years ago, buying my first cellular phone when my wife was pregnant. We poked at the early internet with our dial-up modems. I read newspapers now at coffeeshops. I had despised the way they cluttered up the home I had grown up in–we had a daily paper and the Sunday New York Times which was, back then, the size of piece of carry on luggage; one that barely fits under the seat in front of you.
And they saved bits and pieces of it, so I never knew if I could throw it out.
So I thought it was a grown-up thing but found the continuous presence of newsprint annoying. But as the internet, and cellphones proliferated so did coffeeshops, which had stacks of newspapers paper in them.
So I read them and drank coffee, working that time into my busy or no so busy freelance schedules. The cell phone mutated into a smart phone; the dial-up evolved into a cable-modem. The Newspaper leaked into both of these things, filling them to the brim.
Then… social media, and rage reading and commenting on news from the feed.
I read to my kids at night, every night, for an hour or so, and found that this was the happiest time of my day, as I could read again, in a way, and I was absorbing stories and studying them. But the trivia and news and social media noise overwhelmed my fiction consumption. The ever escalating number of cable channels turned into streaming content and I watched TV at night.
Remember, that kid I had been, the 1000 book reader, had three network channels to choose from. One fuzzy PBS channel. And they played the national anthem over a clip of the flag waving and told you to _go the fuck to bed_ at one every goddamn evening. Do kids even know this? That the TV once upon a time told you to GO TO BED?
And what could you DO in bed? By yourself? As a teen? I mean, other than that?
Read, mostly.
So that three hundred book a year thing was a perfect storm that wouldn’t be replicated, at least not accidentally, ever again in my life–to date.
But now I find myself sick of the news. Sick of COVID. Sick of climate change. Sick of the daily burping and shrieking of politics. Sick, sick, sick of the endless stream of commentary and news. Aching again, for that tribe of friends that smoked dope and listened to music and midnight-wandered golf courses and cemeteries, that drank beer in places were the music wasn’t so loud you couldn’t talk to each other. Not too many of them. But not too few.
So I’m a few weeks into a social media fast. Blogging, after social media, feels like a sensory deprivation tank. Every now and then someone taps on the lid to make sure you’re not dead, but it’s about as appealing a space to be as laying abed at the age of 16 staring at the ceiling wondering why the world sucks so hard.
So, not addictive.
And I’m reading a paperback I found in a box on the street, printed in 1975, when I was twelve. My Dad owned it, so I read it, or most of it, when I was fifteen or sixteen. It’s the Best of Henry Kuttner, and I’ll talk more about it maybe in another post. The stories in it were written between 1941 and 1953, so this is a collection of twenty year old stuff my father had read in the SF magazines as a young man, who he bought again, as those magazines had been tossed by his mother. This collection itself, would be tossed by my mother, and I would find it again, on the side of the road, a year before my father died.
I stand now seventy years away from the earlier stories. I stand now forty five years away from the printing of the book. I stand now forty years from my first reading of it.
And after three weeks off facebook, I find, I can read an entire story without checking my device.
So I read The Twonky, a seminal story, a story that invents entire sub-genres all by itself, and found I had never read it before; I has mixed it up with The Little Black Bag, which is another story about another Twonky (which means an artifact from the future discovered in the past) by Kuttner.
I slip into Kuttner’s voice, his mind, effortlessly; decoding his time takes a bit of work, but as an SF reader that isn’t hard; it’s harder to understand the 40s and 50s than to absorb the SF elements, of course.
it’s good to read again.
I’m going to keep performing this brain surgery on myself. I miss my Facebook friends, but maybe I’ll figure out, how to have it all, someday. But I need to glue the shattered bits of my concentration together again. I have been poisoned by my feed; rage and friendship and humor, doled out like those little tickets that drive kids mad at Chuckee Cheese.
I wanna be someone who can read a book a night again.
One of the hardest things to hear as a beginning writer entering a critical process (with work shoppers, teachers, or editors) is that anyone hates your characters.
It’s even worse when they hate your main character. (MC or POV.) It’s even worser still when likability isn’t their arc; they aren’t supposed to become likable; you though they were already.
I’ve written about this before. But it is a fruitful question.
One of the things writing can reveal is the subjective quality of your own introspection, that is to say, when compared to others.
Specifically, I’m talking about your particular flavor of negativity bias.
One of the problems is that many brains interpret negativity bias as TRUTH. When someone hates your character for articulating in their internal monolog or spoken dialog strong negativity, a common response, for the writer, is to think, “shit, that’s just true. What the fuck is wrong with (this reader) (me)(my writing)( the entire fucking universe, oh God, I’m going to binge watch old episodes of Columbo.)
Relentless negativity bias is exhausting to those that aren’t used to it.
Genre is a sort of flag that tells us how much negativity we are expected to wade through while still empathizing with a character. Of course, great writers can get away with defying these conventions, but I’m not talking about Great Writers. I’m talking about you.
And me.
See what I did there? Did you flinch? Did you agree with me at some level, that we are both not great, and then did you get pissed off and depressed? Because writing about writing is supposed to build you up, not tear you down? Because that is the genre convention?
Most genre characters are slightly idealized and simplified. Especially the ones we are meant to like or inhabit.
It doesn’t have to be much. But a single truly offbeat detail can prevent something from being publishable. A single thought. A single action–on the page.
And we fucking hate your POV. And probably? If you hadn’t written the thing?
So would you. But you don’t see that. Not without help.
I had a friend, a dog person, a very sweet person, who hated Cats. When we saw one outdoors, she would make a little hand-gun, and shoot at it, making the little hand gun POW noise. This person was super supportive of me. But I have cats. I’m allergic to dogs.
At one point I had to tell her, “fucking knock that shit off.” She was driving me nuts.
I can’t say that to a character in a book. At some point I stop wanting to hang out with them. So I stop reading.
Hand gunning cats wasn’t her most salient personality trait. It’s just a detail. But it derailed me.
I think horror characters can be more perfectly realistic… and of course Literature is the place where characters are permitted to be totally realistic. This is one reason so many people hate Literature. (Capital L.) This is probably why Amazon kindle data reveal that most people don’t actually finish literary best sellers.
Of course, they read every word of series genre novels written by not-great writers like you and me. Assuming we get the fucking hang of it. Nobody buys book 5 if they didn’t get through book 4.
Moving on…
Modern audiences, young people, are also often more and more intolerant of stupid opinions and unkind or irrational feelings in anyone. Even a villain. They don’t want to experience that kind of self-talk. They find it damaging and infuriating.
But… Villains can be more realistic too, which is one of the reasons why some people empathize with them. Think of the people who never break with Walter White of Breaking Bad. They bond to him early, when his morality is ambiguous, and stick with him to the bitter end. Some readers are like that.
But many of us want heroes so badly we don’t care about realism. Or, rather, we enjoy a judicious editing that screens us from some realistic negative self talk. Self loathing. Cynicism. Pessimism. Nihilism.
We will put up with slightly boring heroes too. Second bananas and villains will steal the stage.
Don’t worry. You’re doing it right. (I mean, given that you’re not great. Hah. Ouch. SHUT UP!)
Inserting ‘positive’ stuff about your POV may feel fake, un-truthful, but remember the research–you are editing that stuff out. It’s actually in there. People are mixtures of good and bad. The parts you put down on the page are decisions you make.
Those decisions guide readers about the kind of story you are telling.
They can make or break a story.
They lie at the heart of enjoyability. Of what is and what isn’t entertaining.
Whether you are writing literature with a capital L or not.
I attended writing workshop I hadn’t been to in awhile a few years back now, and the nice but slightly awkward person there, uh, one of them, mentioned that she’d heard I’d fallen off the horse. This was news to me. My publications had slackened while I worked on longer stuff, and I guess the consensus of the workshop was I was out of juice.
I hate to think many were happy about this, thinking that a not young writer had gone into retirement and maybe some new blood could use his vacated publication slots.
I shouldn’t care. I’m trying not to care about such things.
John Cheever wrote in a letter that pursuing a career in order to find a group of successful colleagues to be friends with is madness. The cart before the horse. It may happen. It may not. If that’s your focus… maybe get the hell out of the arts and go into marketing. You know, like Willy Loman.
When you drift away from writing, or writing in a certain genre, those working in that genre drift away too. It isn’t a conscious decision. But writing is hard and you simply have no room in your life, often, for anyone or anything that makes that effort even a tiny bit harder. Your slacking off can feel infectious to others.
So, keep your non-writing friends. You may need them desperately from time to time. For years at a time.
Older writers say this infuriating thing to younger writers, that if you don’t have to write, do something else. Instead of reassuring you about a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow, you’re told you should enjoy chasing rainbows.
Because that may well be all that you are doing.
So. Now I smugly assert, at age 58, that I find myself writing, thinking about the WIP, piling up words. Trying to force myself to hit a word count, a set number per day, in the hope of Making A Living writing has receded. The one person I know who went on to that has the willpower of olympic athlete.
And I have come to grips with the fact that I am not one of those. Almost.
But as I process the passing of my parents and our lives together, their lives as I have uncover them in letters and photos and fragments of memory, I find myself lighting out over that inner landscape again.
I’m lighter there. Younger. The light is different. The world is newer and the work beckons and it is never good enough, and I’ve grown to accept that, too. Almost. The work embarrasses me, even the stuff that gets published, or maybe especially that work. We reveal ourselves in our work and if we are decent human beings feel both pride and shame in this.
The sky is full of brooding clouds that will one day merge into darkness, the darkness into which we all disappear. But for now there is light, and color, and power, and Story. A few good writer friends and generous (and award-winning!) editors that give a Flying Fuck. They should be enough.
And the work.
And the shimmering heat mirage of success. I mean the big-time, always somewhere up ahead, never getting any closer. Mocking you and reassuring you. Reminding you that you better enjoy the ride.
There was a time when you had to tell people you were a writer one at a time.
In person.
Working your publications, your agent, your short-listed story in the year’s best, your zine, into the conversation was hard work. Just blurting this out, creating an awkward silence, was about as good as it got.
Still, the best part of being a writer, then and now, is that no one can make you believe you aren’t one without your consent.
John Kennedy Toole wrote the book Confederacy of Dunces, couldn’t sell it and killed himself in despair. Eleven years later, due to the efforts of his mother and Walker Percy, the book was published to critical acclaim and became a canonical work in southern literature.
If you want, you can skip the despair, the suicide, and just be John Kennedy Toole. You’ve written a classic. Everyone else is wrong about it. You’re a goddamn genius.
Anyone you are talking to, who says they’re a writer, might be a genius.
You can’t prove to them they aren’t.
And the evidence of your industry, as a writer, can be modest. Stacks of manuscripts tied with twine. A pile of hand-written moleskin journals. Nowadays? It can be a thumb drive. “I have written over 100 novels that will be beloved by generations. They’re all on this.” Wave thumb drive. “I’m looking for an agent,” is a good way to end that conversation.
Artists kinda need studios, and gear, and they produce stacks of physical stuff, and if they can’t sell it, the stuff piles up.
A writer, at a certain point, might build a shed. Maybe. It’s not necessary.
So. You can write a bit. Then think about the next thing you’ll write, for a long, long time. And in the meantime, you can meet other writers on social media and share a lot of inspirational animated gifs.
You can share your process, inspiration, craft tips, your agony, your ecstasy, pictures of your kids, your dog, your protest signs. You get to be a writer whenever you say you are one. Not an under-employed graphic designer, or a retired person, or a kid out of college living with his parents who can’t land a job or a person living on disability or a stay at home parent taking a career hiatus or a person working any number of dead end jobs to make ends meet or a trust fund kid who sleeps till noon and gets drunk every night. So many identities are hard to own.
You can pretend to be a writer instead of being those things.
And… you can always stop pretending, and write; write more; write every day, and work at making your writing as good as it can be.
You can fake it till you make it. Sit down. Make words. Slip inside them.
Be Mr. Orange. Become the bad ass you want to be. Talk yourself into it.
Fool everyone else. Fool yourself.
Accept that we are all fools.
Set aside the dog eared manuscript and write a new one. You’re most writerly when you’re writing.
My friend Amy Solomon was feeling despair as the new reports of massive, industrial scale child abuse paid for by our tax dollars spilled out last week.
“I can’t stand it,” she told me on Facebook.
After she created a candlelight vigil event.
We’ve all seen the places we should send money, and I think most of us have sent some, or we have continued to support the ACLU and other groups, maybe our democratic candidate, but there is something about paying other people to do this work for you that is not satisfying.
Creating this event herself felt super weird to me. Did she have a permit? What would it matter… 10, 20, 50, 100 people. Would we be hassled? Wasn’t someone organizing something later, bigger, where I could go where I was told, and chant in unison? Where the media could under-report the size of the crowd, and take pictures of the anti-protestors to run side by side with us?
I mean, did we have permission to do this? Then I laughed, out loud, not LOLing, but actually laughing out loud.
Did we have permission to do this!
I agreed instantly. I’ve learned that sometimes other people remind me of what I really want to do.
In response to the candlelight vigil (we skipped the candles and walked with signs) some angry person went off on Amy on Facebook, in that way people do easily on social media, about how the Trumpers don’t care about our protests or our sadness, how the time for that is past.
I wondered how to respond.
Angrily? “Fuck you. What are you doing? Fucking holier than though piece of shit, you.”
Then, less angry, “It may not do much, but the one thing I do know is that anything in the real world beats whining in social media, like you.” You dumb fuck. I leave that part off of course. I”m being less angry.
There’s the CBT therapy response, which goes, “I understand why you feel that way. I feel like that too sometimes. What are you doing that you think is more effective? I’m open to suggestions. You obviously want to stop this too, so we are on the same side.”
Then, I hit on the real response.
“Sorry you feel hopeless. I didn’t do this for you. I didn’t do it for the Trumpers. To some degree, I didn’t even do it for the kids in the cages, at the bottom of this, we do these things for ourselves, so we aren’t the people who do nothing.”
Not to be smug, or holier than thou, or delusional about how much impact we are having.
There is a great scene in the last season of Babylon Five in which Londo, a diplomat representing a fading power who dreams of making his empire great again, whispers to a mysterious alien in a bar. This leads to the Great War, that turns into a genocide Londo grows to hate.
When it’s over Londo is plagued by nightmares, which become a fatal illness. In his visions he confronts Gkar, a diplomat for the race swept into camps and slaughtered.
“There was nothing I could do to stop it! I would be court martialed and shot!”
Gkar explains without rancor that Londo had to do something anyway.
It didn’t matter if anything he did could possible work.
Londo had to do it for himself. You have to do this for yourself.
To be a person you can live with.
You can’t make anyone in this world do a damn thing. As Robert Heinlein said, the worst you can do is kill them.
The only person you control, is yourself. The only real voices in your head are your own.
Tell yourself to be the person you want to be. It’s the only way you become them.
Your ideals, your humanity, becomes worthless when you don’t, and you might not consciously know it, but that voice inside reminds you, deep down that voice you conjure, knows if you are lying. It knows you.
Either way. Do this for yourself, your best self, and or your God, if you want to think that way.
And even if all the protest signs do is mark you for ridicule, for persecution, you still have to hold them.